Is The Twilight Saga: The Official Illustrated Guide by Stephenie Meyer fiction or nonfiction? After reading the detailed portraits of the characters' lives contained within it, one might surmise that it is a work of fiction, especially since their backstories are told as fact when they are clearly the constructs of Meyer's fictional Twilight Saga world. However, there are sections, like the question and answer series between Meyer and fellow author Shannon Hale, which are nonfiction through and through. So, which is it? Both, apparently.
Last week, The Guide debuted at number four on IndieBound bestseller book list with the categorization, "Hardcover Fiction Bestsellers." USA Today also deemed it fiction on their list.
Now, The Wall Street Journal has unveiled its bestseller book list for the week of April 17th (The Guide hit shelves on April 12th), and The Guide debuted at number one!
Not that it's terribly important given the good news, but WSJ categorized The Guide as "Hardcover Nonfiction."
USA Today described The Guide as a "Definitive encyclopedic reference to the Twilight Saga by the author" when placing it in the fiction bin, so what could the WSJ be seeing about it to coin the book nonfiction? Your thoughts? Which category would you associate with this newest Twilight Saga addition?
Examiner.com
~Robstenfan
Sunday, April 24, 2011
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
0 comments:
Post a Comment